His disbelief isn't terribly off-putting; he hadn't believed her in his nightmare either, and his reaction then had been the opposite of amused. The mention of Lucifer, though, is very unexpected, but after a moment of dubious frowning she finds the lore that tells her he's technically an angel too. Another difficult brother of Gabriel's, then, to say the least.

She's considering asking him more about it when there's a confusing shift in his mood, and she regards him with some concern. But that's familiar too, accidentally bringing up something unpleasant, as is the subsequent attempt at distraction, and she nods willingly enough. "Ah, yes, of course."

As they start making their way over to the stage, she tilts her head up at him and adds tentatively, "But I was not put up to this. I can still prove it, if you like."